Newcastle managed to beat the better performers Sheffield United, thanks to their solid defensive actions and the perfect timing of their attacking ones. Despite Sheffield Uniteds dominance while having only 27% of the possession, the Newcastle players were able to take advantage of their opponents mistakes, while making sure to not allow lapses in their own defence.
The lack of strong finishing by Sheff Uniteds front duo helped them too, although they conceded a few chances and the only reason for them keeping the clean sheet is the outstanding performance by the keeper Martin Dúbravka.
The Magpies worked strongly under pressure, and despite lacking the perfect build-up and structure, they managed to make things work timing their attacks well.
This tactical analysis aims to break-down both teams tactics using analysis and answer why Sheffield United failed in their efforts to score, despite controlling the game.
Lineups

Chris Wilder opted for a 3-5-2 formation, starting off with Dean Henderson on the goal. His back-three contained Jack OConnel, John Egan and Chris Basham. Enda Stevens and George Baldock were serving as the wing-backs, having John Fleck, Oliver Norwood and John Lundstram covering the middle. The front two included Billy Sharp and Oliver McBurnie.
Steve Bruce chose to focus on the teams defensive stability and lined them up in a 5-4-1 scheme. The best performer Martin Dúbravka covered the goal. When out of possession the defensive players were Jetro Willems, Paul Dummett, Ciaran Clark, Federico Fernández and Javier Manquillo. Jonjo Shelvey and Isaac Hayder were covering the centre areas, trying to deliver the ball to Andy Carroll who was chosen for a lone striker. The wings were covered by Allan Saint-Maximin and Miguel Almirón.

![PSG Vs Newcastle United [1–1] – Champions League 2025/2026: A Tactical Arm-Wrestle In Paris – Tactical Analysis 3 PSG Vs Newcastle United [1–1] – Champions League 2025/2026: A Tactical Arm-Wrestle In Paris – Tactical Analysis](https://totalfootballanalysis.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/PSG-Vs-Newcastle-20252026-350x250.png)
![Napoli Vs Chelsea [2–3] – Champions League 2025/2026: How Game Management Cost Antonio Conte – Tactical Analysis 4 Napoli Vs Chelsea [2–3] – Champions League 2025/2026: How Game Management Cost Antonio Conte – Tactical Analysis](https://totalfootballanalysis.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Napoli-Vs-Chelsea-20252026-350x250.png)



![Arsenal Vs Manchester United [2–3] – Premier League 2025/2026: How Michael Carrick Punished Mikel Arteta – Tactical Analysis 8 Arsenal vs Manchester United](https://totalfootballanalysis.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Arsenal-2-3-Man-United-tactical-analysis-350x250.png)