Montreal Impact visited the Big Apple on an MLS midweek fixture where the guests significantly reduced the New York Red Bulls’ threat and won the match in the second half with scoring two goals. This tactical analysis will reveal both teams’ approaches and how Montreal beat Chris Armas’s side. 

There were no clear favourites, on one hand, the visitors had a slightly bigger chance as they doing good in the MLS Eastern Conference though. With recorded five wins, four draws and two losses they are on the upper half of the table. 

On the other hand, NYRB started to get into the better form after a pretty bad season start. Last week they achieved a magnificent victory against LA Galaxy. In addition to that, the previous meetings make NYRB’s side hopes stronger since Montreal the last victory at Red Bull Arena was in 2016. 

LineupsMLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact

The visitors switched from the usual 4-3-3 formation to match the opponent’s structure thus Rémi Garde deployed 5-3-2 system where Rudy Camacho started between Raitala and Diallo in the middle of the defence. Brault-Guillard and Lovitz employed as a wing-back. On the midfield department, Shome and Browne replaced Taïder and Azira. While Ignacio Piatti is out due to his injury, Jackson-Hamel and Urruti started upfront. 

The home side also has a painful absence, namely Bradley Wright-Phillips who was usually replaced by White, but this time Tom Barlow made it to the starting XI as a lone forward in a 5-4-1 system that Chris Armas recently deployed. Although it was more likely a 3-3-3-1 in possession and in defence, the formation transformed into a 5-1-3-1/5-4-1 shape, which I will explain below.

How the 3-3-3-1 of New York Red Bulls worked

First of all, it is important to see how NYRB’s structure worked in this match. Usually, they positioned high right from the beginning in order to attack and press the opponent. As a consequence of that the wing-backs, Lawrence and Lade pushed out of their positions from the base 5-4-1 shape and mostly occupied the wider areas of the midfield next to the touchline.

In front of the three centre-backs, Davis added more cover to the centre between the defensive and attacking department. Due to the wing-backs involvement in attack the wingers, Muyl and Royer could stay narrow – mostly in the half-spaces – and Rzatkowski was between them.

MLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact
Barlow occupied the opponent’s back line while Muyl, Rzatkowski and Royer are narrow and shifted to the ball side. The wing-backs moved forward and provided width. Davis stayed deep.

Chris Armas’ goal was to create a high-intensity game both in the possession and out of it. They used long balls towards Barlow and the front players always shifted to the ball side to create short passing options around the ball. In addition to this, New York Red Bulls often tried to create crossing opportunities.

MLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact
All the attacking players in a small area to provide a target to layoffs.

Furthermore, during the match NYRB frequently pressed high. In this sequences, the striker formed the first line of the press with the aim to press the side-backs with curved runs the ball-sided winger moved out to press diagonally.

MLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact
The usual pressing movements of New York Red Bulls. The goal was to force the opponent wide and trap Diallo or Raitala.

Montreal Impact’s approach

As I mentioned earlier, the guests opted for a 5-3-2 system to match NYRB’s structure. With this Montreal were able to close down the opposition wing-backs while they have enough presence and cover in the middle. Also,  with the two strikers, they had enough target up front for the long balls. In possession, the wing-backs pushed forward next to the touchline and Browne often moved to the attacking right half-space or even to the first line.

MLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact
Both sides’ formations and the usual movements.

In Montreal’s attacking play it was clear from the beginning that they would be targeting the left half-space and the wing. They had two breakthroughs in the opening first two minutes. Usually, Raitala passed behind NYRB’s first lines of presses, targeting the space behind Muyl where Urruti dropped mostly around the halfway line. Davis could not shift quickly enough and Lovitz occupied the opposition wing-back thus space was uncovered there. Then they used quick one-twos to get behind NYRB’s shape, as the image shows below.

MLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact
Quick one-twos between Raitala, Lovitz and the nearby central midfielder.

They often used this pattern, although New York Red Bulls started to pay attention to this as the game wore on and closed them down. Another opportunity was to pull out the opposition defenders and quickly fill the vacated space. Here is an instance where Brault-Guillard pass behind the opponent defence targeting Browne’s run.

MLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact
Browne dropped which pulled out Tarek while Lawrence moved out to press the opposition wing-back. Montreal should use this scheme more often.

Moreover, Montreal in attack emphasised long balls in behind the opposition shape. Although it was not too effective because lots of counter-attacks got stopped or delayed due to NYRB’s intense counter-pressing which often made Montreal players act in haste.

MLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact
Intense counter-pressing of New York Red Bulls that made difficult for Montreal to attack or initiate the counter-attack.

Against Montreal’s defence

When NYRB tried to build from the back they struggled against Montreal’s defensive block due to the isolation and the lack of penetration power.

MLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact
No passing option for Tarek because all players pushed up on the pitch and all marked or cover shadowed by Montreal.

Here is another occasion where Montreal made a good defensive job thus New York Red Bulls suffered against Montreal’s 5-3-2.

MLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact
Again isolation on the ball. All the NYRB players were marked or the passing route was blocked.

One thing that the home side tried to do is long balls towards Barlow, however, these attempts were not effective. MLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact

Second Half

After the break, Montreal started to exercise dominant play as a natural response to NYRB’s lead. This gave them longer possession phase at opponent’s half which allowed to more players join the attack. Thus not just Browne pushed forward but Shome also did and sometimes Piette too.

MLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact
Piette, Browne and Shome (orange circles) occupied high areas.

Although committing lots of players in high areas does not mean they become more dangerous since New York Red Bulls were always able to quickly put pressure on the ball. Montreal struggled to break down this defence. Only the corners gave them the opportunity to score and they did.

MLS 2018/19 Tactical Analysis Statistics: New York Red Bulls vs Montreal Impact
NYRB’s formations throughout the game.

After the equaliser goal, Chris Armas sent in a midfielder (Fernandez) to replace a centre-back (Tarek) and Kaku for Muyl. This allowed switching to a 4-1-4-1 formation which in possession was more like a 4-2-3-1. Of course, this caused some risk at the back since Montreal’s front two were left with just NYRB’s two centre-backs.

Finally, Montreal were able to score the winning goal in the 79th minutes after a questionable decision that gave them the penalty.

Conclusion

None of the goals occurred from open play which shows us that neither sides allowed too much for the opponent. Especially Montreal Impact who significantly reduced New York Red Bulls attacking power. NYRB could not excel danger for the guests’ goal as they had only 0,44 expected goals.


If you love tactical analysis, then you’ll love the digital magazines from totalfootballanalysis.com – a guaranteed 100+ pages of pure tactical analysis covering topics from the Premier League, Serie A, La Liga, Bundesliga and many, many more. Buy your copy of the May issue for just ₤4.99 here, or even better sign up for a ₤50 annual membership (12 monthly issues plus the annual review) right here.