Manchester United supporters have been through some tough times in recent seasons, but many hoped the 2024–25 campaign might offer a fresh start.
Unfortunately, it’s been anything but.
Under the guidance of manager Ruben Amorim, the Red Devils are slipping ever closer to the bottom of the Premier League.
This is not what fans expect of a club that prides itself on competing for titles.
Even more surprising is the rumour that United are thinking of selling one of their brightest young players, Alejandro Garnacho.
Is this a terrible mistake, or could it turn out to be a clever way to rebuild?
The Season So Far
Manchester United’s season has been full of ups and downs, with more lows than highs.
Many expected big improvements after the change in management.
However, the results haven’t been kind.
United’s current position sees them hovering in the lower half of the table, which is a far cry from the glory days of the past.
The squad seems unable to put together a consistent run of good form, and this inconsistency has led to pointed fingers in every direction.
Ruben Amorim raised a few eyebrows when he famously suggested that this might be the worst Manchester United team in the club’s history.
That statement might have been born out of frustration, but it shows the scale of the challenges he faces.
The team’s confidence took a hit after a 3-1 loss to Brighton at Old Trafford, which marked the fourth defeat in five home matches – a run that hadn’t been seen in well over a century.
While they’ve managed an odd positive result here and there, like a surprising win over Arsenal, these flashes of quality haven’t been enough to turn the season around.
With so much at stake, people are understandably looking for someone or something to blame.
Players have been criticised for lacking commitment, the manager has taken responsibility for poor performances, and the board is under pressure to find solutions.
Among all this chaos, certain players still draw interest from other clubs.
Alejandro Garnacho is one such player, but rather than building the team around him, some at Old Trafford appear willing to let him leave.
Garnacho’s Potential
It’s clear that United haven’t had much to celebrate lately, which makes Garnacho’s situation all the more intriguing.
He’s one of the rare talents in the squad who has caught the eye of rival teams.
Reports suggest that Napoli are especially keen, and the initial valuation of around £75 million has dropped to about £55 million.
For a club struggling with funds and looking to make major changes, such a figure can be tempting.
Garnacho’s skill on the ball and his pace down the flank have given fans reason to be excited.
At just 20 years old, he’s got time on his side to develop even further.
Anyone who has watched him play can see how he can change a game in an instant, whether it’s beating a defender or creating a scoring chance.
He’s also got a certain flair that’s often missing in a side low on confidence.
In a team with few bright points, he feels like the sort of player United would normally work hard to keep.
However, despite all this, there are questions about his attitude and commitment.
Some commentators say Garnacho’s work rate off the ball isn’t always up to scratch, while others claim he’s not quite clicking in Ruben Amorim’s system.
The manager is trying to build a certain style of play, and if Garnacho doesn’t fit the plan, it raises the question: why keep him if there’s a big pile of cash on the table?
Reasons For a Possible Sale
There are several reasons why United might consider selling Garnacho, even if it looks strange from the outside.
One of the biggest is money.
It’s no secret that the club wants to sign a proven striker, and top-class forwards don’t come cheap.
By selling a young prospect, especially one who came up through the ranks, United could improve their financial situation.
This move would also help with Profitability and Sustainability Regulations, which encourage clubs to keep their books balanced.
Another factor is the manager’s preference.
If Ruben Amorim has doubts about Garnacho’s role in the team, then a transfer might seem logical.
There’s no point forcing a player into a system that doesn’t suit him, particularly when the club is so short on funds that they need to move people on before bringing in reinforcements.
Trading Garnacho would free up both money and space in the squad for players who might align better with Amorim’s style.
Then there’s the issue of Garnacho’s mentality, which some reporters say might be a sticking point.
Napoli and Chelsea, who are also said to be interested, both want assurances about his attitude before finalising any move.
For United, if they believe these worries are genuine, they may feel it’s best to cash in now before he becomes harder to sell.
But there’s always a danger that you sell a talented youngster too soon, only to watch him flourish somewhere else.
Risk and Reward: The Gamble That Could Backfire
This is where the real question comes in: is it smart to sell one of the few players who might actually attract a big transfer fee, or is it a recipe for disaster? There’s no doubt that Garnacho has the ability to be a game-changer.
In a team that’s desperately searching for a spark, letting him go could leave United lacking exactly the sort of creativity that’s so difficult to replace.
Cashing in on Garnacho would be a gamble – one that might leave you with money in your pocket but also leave you wondering if you’d have ended up richer if you’d never gambled in the first place.
UK casino operators and betting shops rely on people making bad bets like this -it’s how they stay in business.
Manchester United have already seen plenty of talented players slip through their fingers over the years, and supporters have witnessed ex-Reds go on to great success at other clubs.
If Garnacho becomes a star elsewhere, there will be plenty of people asking why Old Trafford couldn’t have shown a bit more patience.
In the end, the question “Mishap or Masterplan?” doesn’t have a straightforward answer.
If Garnacho stays and starts playing to his full potential, he could be part of a bright future for United.
If he goes, the funds might help rebuild a squad that badly needs a new sense of purpose.
Either choice has its dangers, and with the club struggling so badly in the league, it’s hard to predict which way things will turn out.
The only thing certain is that this season has brought nothing but uncertainty, and the decision about Garnacho’s future could be one of the biggest calls the club makes this year.
